As the final arbiter of the law, the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) is charged with ensuring the American people the promise of equal justice under law. In doing so, it serves as both the guardian and interpreter of the Constitution. According to the Supreme Court’s official description, the Court fulfills this responsibility through its role as the nation’s highest judicial authority.
The Supreme Court consists of nine justices: one Chief Justice and eight Associate Justices. All are appointed for life. The number of Associate Justices, currently fixed at eight, is determined by Congress. Whenever a vacancy occurs because of the retirement or death of a justice, the President nominates a replacement who must then be confirmed by the United States Senate through its constitutional duty of providing “advice and consent” under Article II of the Constitution.
As the highest court in the nation, SCOTUS issues decisions that are generally considered final unless the Court later overturns one of its own precedents. In many cases, the only practical means of addressing the impact of a Supreme Court ruling is through legislation enacted by Congress.
Unfortunately, the Senate confirmation process has become heavily influenced by partisan politics. The majority party often plays a decisive role in determining whether a nominee is confirmed or rejected. Even when a President’s party controlled the Senate, the confirmation process was once presumed to be considerably more rigorous because Senate rules allowed unlimited debate, a practice known as the filibuster. However, this practice of filibustering only delayed the vote and served no meaningful purpose and is practically useless (see article End Filibusters).
Ending debate required a cloture vote of three-fifths of the Senate, or 60 senators. In April 2017, the Senate changed this rule and reduced the number of votes needed to end debate on Supreme Court nominations to a simple majority of 51 votes, a change commonly referred to as the “nuclear option.” As a result, if the President’s party is in the Senate minority, a nomination can face overwhelming political obstacles, as demonstrated during the events surrounding a Supreme Court vacancy in 2016.
The framers of the Constitution envisioned a Senate composed of highly educated, wise, principled, and civic-minded statesmen and stateswomen who would help guide both the President and the nation in selecting the most qualified jurists available. Instead, the nomination process has increasingly become a partisan struggle for political power, often overshadowing a nominee’s qualifications, judicial philosophy, and professional merits.
In this sense, the former requirement for a supermajority vote functioned as an important check and balance. When a simple Senate majority changed the rules to bypass that requirement, a key safeguard was effectively removed. In recent years, many Americans have come to view the Court as increasingly ideological, a perception often reinforced by sharply divided majority and dissenting opinions in major cases. These developments appear to have diminished the respect and confidence that the Supreme Court once enjoyed among many citizens and observers around the world. To some, the Court now appears less an independent institution and more a participant in partisan power politics.
Can “We the People,” through Cooperative Socio Capitalism (CSC), reform this broken nomination system and restore the Court’s prestige, independence, and public trust? Several reforms could be considered through the national referendum process envisioned under CSC.
The first proposal is to restore a Senate confirmation requirement of at least a three-fifths majority, or perhaps even a two-thirds majority, for all Supreme Court nominees with the Senate having no power to alter it.
The second proposal is to require all confirmation votes to be conducted by secret ballot, also known as the Australian ballot, under which a voter’s identity remains anonymous (please read article on Secret Ballot – House & Senate). No party whip can be issued ahead of the confirmation vote. Only the total number of votes cast for and against a nominee would be made public, without any disclosure of party affiliation or individual voting records. This approach would preserve the independence of senators and reduce opportunities for intimidation, coercion, blackmail, political retaliation, or vote buying.
In addition, cash payments, paid lobbying linked directly to confirmation votes, intimidation, blackmail, and any form of vote-buying aimed at influencing senators would be prohibited and subject to strict penalties, including jail term (discussed further under the article on Senate Reform).
Before any secret-ballot vote is conducted, senators from either party would be permitted to participate in a structured debate concerning the nominee’s qualifications, judicial record, and any potential conflicts of interest. Each senator could speak for up to fifteen minutes, with total debate limited to four hours. All senators would be required to cast a vote, either in person or through an approved remote process if physical attendance were impossible.
An obvious question arises: What happens if a nominee fails to meet the required threshold?
Under a proposed constitutional amendment approved by the people, a second secret ballot would be conducted to augment the Senate vote. This second ballot would be electronic and would include all members of the House of Representatives, including delegates, as well as all sitting Supreme Court justices except the nominee. If a congressional seat were vacant because of death or resignation, that vote would be temporarily exercised by the governor of the corresponding state.
The nominee would then be confirmed if a simple majority of the combined first and second ballots were obtained. If the nominee still failed to secure a majority, the nomination would be rejected and the process would begin again with a new nominee.
Additional reforms to the Supreme Court could also be considered through the national referendum process:
A. Fixed Membership
The size of the Supreme Court shall remain permanently fixed at nine members: one Chief Justice and eight Associate Justices. Congress would not have the authority to alter the size of the Court. Any change would require approval through a national referendum.
B. Protection of the Confirmation Process
The Senate would be prohibited from changing its rules in ways that circumvent the confirmation requirements established by the Constitution or by national referendum.
C. Supermajority Decisions in Supreme Court Cases
For any case before the Supreme Court, a final judgment would require either a unanimous decision or a vote with no more than one dissenting or abstaining justice (at least 8 out of 9). If this threshold were not achieved, the justices would be given one opportunity to revise the opinion and conduct a second secret ballot.
If, after the second ballot, the Court still failed to achieve the required level of agreement, no judgment would be issued. Instead, a simple majority of the justices would refer the matter to a national referendum for resolution.
D. National Roster of Eminent Judges
The President would have no power to nominate just any individual to the Supreme Court. Eligible nominees would first need to appear on a national roster of “eminent judges” maintained by the National Bar Association. Only judges with distinguished records of jurisprudence and demonstrated excellence in judicial service would qualify.
E. Term Limits
All Supreme Court justices, including the Chief Justice, would serve a single ten-year term. At the conclusion of that term, a successor would be nominated and confirmed. No extensions or reappointments would be permitted. If a justice dies before the end of their term, a new justice will be sworn in for a full 10-year term.
F. Gender Representation
Four of the eight Associate Justice positions would be reserved for women. In addition, the office of Chief Justice would alternate between a man and a woman every ten years or earlier if the CJ dies before the end of term.
G. Annual Health Certification
Each justice would undergo an annual medical evaluation conducted by an independent panel of physicians. The purpose would be to ensure that every member of the Court remains physically and cognitively capable of performing the duties of the office.
Next Article – Secret Ballot – House & Senate
